| It’s an interesting task for someone who is in a documentary to write a balanced review of that very documentary. But Alex Harris does an admirable job in his TGC review of Prime Video’s new limited docuseries, Shiny Happy People, in which he appears as an interviewed expert. In editing Harris’s review, I was struck by its refreshing nuance. Writing as someone reared in the Christian homeschooling world the series critiques, Harris nonetheless engages Shiny Happy People in a charitable, non-defensive way. He has both positive and critical things to say about the series, and finds things to learn in it even in spite of its flaws. This sort of posture is all too rare in today’s outrage-driven, all-or-nothing, pick-a-side world. Yes, evangelicals have reason to be wary of Hollywood’s tendency to seize upon the most egregious scandals and build out broad-brushed narratives about “evangelical culture” from there. And yes, the jump from a specific story to “systemic” implications can often be too swift and sometimes reckless. But even if these fears are founded, we can still watch things like Shiny Happy People or The Secrets of Hillsong and appreciate the valid questions they ask and the hard truths they expose. “As Christians, we should be willing to listen to and humbly learn from criticism, even when imperfectly delivered,” Harris writes in his review. “For those willing to answer that call, Shiny Happy People is a good place to start.” |