March 14, 2025
TGC
The Book Drop: Biweekly reflections on books and reading by TGC’s books editor

Dear Reader,

Happy Pi Day! It’s the day some choose to celebrate the wonders of the most famous irrational number by consuming a circular dessert.

Did you know we came close to having this faux holiday on a different date? In 1897, the Indiana House of Representatives unanimously passed a bill to change the value of pi to 3.2. Thankfully the bill never passed the Senate, which kept that mathematical heresy from becoming law.

The curious account of one gadfly’s quest to mangle mathematics by redefining a universal value reminds us that errors can take root even in the most rigorously objective disciplines. And those mistakes could have immense repercussions.

Yet the existence of errors—even those that almost make it into law—aren’t proof that math isn’t true. They’re evidence that people sometimes make convincing mistakes.

In Heretic, journalist Catherine Nixey discounts Christianity because doctrinal error has existed (and continues to exist). Since some believers invented strange stories about Jesus and others incorporated native folklore, she argues there’s no hope of discovering the truth.

It struck me as I reviewed her book that had she treated the canonical Gospels as carefully as the extrabiblical texts she highlights, she might have come to a different conclusion. I’m thankful for the work of the church fathers in hammering out so many doctrinal controversies as they studied Scripture together.

I’m also thankful (to a lesser degree) for the Indiana State Senate of 1897. Without them, I might not be eating pie today.

Happy reading!

Andrew Spencer

Associate Editor

 

New from TGC

Have You Heard the One About the ‘Infancy Gospel of Thomas’?

Book Review

Have You Heard the One About the ‘Infancy Gospel of Thomas’?

Andrew Spencer

“Nixey recounts her initial wonder at the skepticism of Celsus: ‘Did you know this? I certainly didn’t, and I had been brought up in a house that was quite religious.’ Her surprise reminds us not to repeat her parent's failure of discipleship. Like dad jokes, apologetic arguments must be repeated every generation because, though there’s no new material, we have a new audience.” Read the review.

True Health Isn’t Just Physical

Book Review

True Health Isn’t Just Physical

Kathryn Butler

“We all strive for wellness. Yet what does it mean to be ‘well’? That’s a central question Tyler J. VanderWeele takes up in ‘A Theology of Health: Wholeness and Human Flourishing.’ VanderWeele is an epidemiologist who directs the Human Flourishing Program at Harvard and codirects the Initiative on Health, Spirituality, and Religion. His work guides academics toward a cohesive and all-encompassing view of health with the Christian worldview at its center. According to VanderWeele, true health doesn’t hinge on technology or trends but rather on union with Christ and conformity to God’s will.” Read the review.

Mystic at Heart: John Eldredge’s Remedy for the Digital Age

Book Review

Mystic at Heart: John Eldredge’s Remedy for the Digital Age

Caleb Wait

  Don’t Buy into a Revisionist Gospel

Book Review

Don’t Buy into a Revisionist Gospel

Harrison Perkins

Advertisement
 

Links for the Reading Life

1.

Kathryn Butler, “Here Be Dragons: What Christians Need to Know About Romantasy” (The Gospel Coalition)

“Whatever its origins, romantasy has soared in popularity in recent years. Onyx Storm sold 2.7 million copies in its first week, breaking a 20-year record. At the time of this writing, Yarros’s books occupy the top two spots on the New York Times bestseller list for hardcover fiction and the top three spots on Amazon’s ‘most sold’ list. Maas, another author driving sales in the category, has also seen meteoric success; her A Court of Thorns and Roses series has sold more than 13 million copies.

“Why have these books achieved such a wide readership over the last few years? Even more importantly, what should Christians know about romantasy—and how can we guard our hearts as these titles become increasingly prevalent?”

2.

Alister McGrath, “Following the Clues of the Universe” (Plough)

“How do we make sense of our universe? Of ourselves? Human beings seem inherently driven to seek meaning in life, sensing that something deeper lies beyond the horizons of our present experience that makes life worthwhile and fulfilling. The cultural anthropologist Clifford Geertz suggests that humanity ‘cannot live in a world it is unable to understand.’ We are ‘symbolizing, conceptualizing, meaning-seeking animals,’ who want to ‘make sense out of experience, and give it some form and order.’

“Human beings are always seeking meaning. Yet this ‘meaning’ proves elusive. It is not something that we observe; rather, it is something we have to uncover by interpreting what we observe. The universe stays silent about its own significance, compelling us, as its observers and interpreters, to discover ‘some form and order.’ P. D. James, who created the investigator and poet Adam Dalgliesh of New Scotland Yard, famously remarked that ‘what the detective story is about is not murder but the restoration of order.’ Meaning is something that we uncover by following clues and discovering where they lead us.”

3.

Peter Conrad, “‘He Contains the Whole of Literature’: Is Dickens Better Than Shakespeare?” (The Guardian)

“One Shakespearean motto lodged in Dickens’s mind, almost as an irritant. This was Prospero’s boast in The Tempest about his ‘so potent art,’ by which he means the magic that whips up storms and even resurrects the dead. Dickens was also a magician, who performed conjuring tricks at parties and thought of his poetic metaphors as verbal spells; he frequently quoted Prospero’s phrase, as if quietly asking whose art was the more potent. At the end of the play, Shakespeare’s magus wearily discards his book of charms and resigns himself to impotent mortality: he cannot match the creative energy of Dickens, who said that when writing he often felt that his head was about to explode ‘like a fired shell.’”

 
TGC

The Gospel Coalition
8520 Allison Pointe Boulevard, Suite 220, Indianapolis, IN, 46250

Take control of your inbox
Manage your preferences and choose which newsletters you want to receive or unsubscribe from all emails.