×
Browse

I’m doing a chapter-by-chapter summary of  James Davison Hunter’s new book, To Change the World: The Irony, Tragedy, and Possibility of Christianity in the Late Modern World (Oxford University Press, 2010). Today we move to chapter 5, “Evidence in History.” The goal is to take the perspective of chapter 4 (on what culture is and how it changes) and examine how it stands up to the hard realities of history.

Hunter provides an overview survey of some key historical events;

  1. The growth of Christianity
  2. The conversion of Barbarian Europe
  3. The Carolingian Renaissance (late eighth and ninth centuries)
  4. The Reformation
  5. Successor Movements (Awakenings, antislavery reforms, revival)
  6. Beyond Christianity (Enlightenment, European socialism [c. 1864-1914])

The big idea in this survey is that ideas can only have revolutionary, world-changing consequences when certain kinds of structural conditions are in place.

The common view of cultural change (ala Colson) does not offer a useful account of any of these periods. “The beliefs and values of ordinary people have a place in the unfolding drama; but it is neither the central nor the decisive place in the instigation and direction of change itself” (p. 77, my emphasis).

Nor does cultural change comes from the mere creation of cultural artifacts (ala Crouch). The creation of cultural goods has a place, but artifacts are largely meaningless “absent critical sociological conditions surrounding the production and consumption of material goods” (p. 77).

What, then, is decisive?

In history, “at every point of challenge and change, we find a rich source of patronage that provided resources for intellectuals and educators who, in the context of dense networks, imagine, theorize, and propagate an alternative universe.” Along with the elites there are often “artists, poets, musicians, and the like who symbolize, narrate, and popularize this vision.” New institutions give tangible expression by forming and enacting that culture. The result is a “vibrant cultural economy that gives articulation in multiple forms, and critical mass to the ideals and practices and goods of the alternative culture in ways that both defy yet still resonate with the existing social environment” (pp. 78, 79, my emphasis).

In the next chapter we’ll look at the place of Christianity in contemporary America.

LOAD MORE
Loading