Read through the complete passage for this study, 2 Samuel 21–24. Then review the questions below concerning this section of 1–2 Samuel and write your notes on them. (For further background, see the ESV Study Bible, pages 576–584; available online at www.esv.org.)
The last four chapters of 1–2 Samuel form an epilogue. Its six sections are assembled in a chiastic structure—the first relating to the last, the second relating to the fifth, and the third and fourth relating to each other:
- A king’s sin brings catastrophe; David intervenes (21:1–14)
- David’s mighty men in action (21:15–22)
- David’s poetic reflection on deliverance (22:1–51)
- David’s poetic “last words” (23:1–7)
- David’s mighty men by name (23:9–39)
- A king’s sin brings catastrophe; David repents (24:1–25)
Observe this structure for yourself, noting any other similarities you see in the corresponding pairs of passages.
Having observed this literary structure, we will examine the corresponding pairs of texts together.
Two Famines (21:1–14; 24:1–25)
We have no other record of Saul’s attempting to eradicate the Gibeonites (21:2), but we do find biblical background explaining why Saul’s intentions were so serious and sinful. Read Joshua 9:3–21 and discuss how that passage illuminates the seriousness of Saul’s actions.
While some aspects of the first famine story (2 Sam. 21:1–14) may seem surprising or strange, what broader theological issues might they illustrate?
The taking of a census (a counting of population) was not always sinful—indeed, Numbers is a whole book about numbering God’s people! But David’s census is clearly sinful (24:10), although we are not explicitly told why. Based on a recurring theme in the book (see 1 Sam. 2:9–10; 10:23–24; 14:6; 16:7; 17:4–11, 45, 47), why do you think David’s census is sinful?
While 2 Samuel 24 ends on the happy note of David’s intercession and the Lord’s mercy (vv. 18–25), something even more significant is happening. Read 1 Chronicles 21:28–22:1, which retells the same scene with more detail. What is the significance of this moment for the broader plan of God?
Two Accounts of the Mighty Men (21:15–22; 23:9–39)
Having already read of David’s defeat of Goliath in 1 Samuel 17, we might think that 2 Samuel 21:19 is in error when it claims that Elhanan killed Goliath. But this is no contradiction if Goliath was a family name or nickname (see ESV Study Bible note on 2 Sam. 21:19). However, we should consider the relationship between the two Philistine wars from another angle. Who was unwilling to fight in 1 Samuel 17? Who is willing to fight in 2 Samuel 21? What does this say about the state of the army before and after David’s reign?
When the Philistine warriors are described (21:15–22), what is emphasized? How might this emphasis relate to previous narratives and general themes of 1–2 Samuel?
How does your answer to the above relate to the descriptions of David’s mighty men in 2 Samuel 21:15–22 and 23:8–39?
The accounts of David’s mighty men include both positive and negative elements. This signifies that, on the whole, David’s kingdom includes both weaknesses and strengths. What are they? (Note especially 21:15–17 and 23:11.)
Two Concluding Poems (22:1–51; 23:1–7)
In a chiastic structure, the middle section is often of central importance. In this case, the middle section is the poetry of 22:1–51 and 23:1–7. In light of the narratives on either side, how does the poetry stand out? How do David’s prayers compare and contrast with the scenes before and after?
Recall from earlier in our study how Hannah’s prayer (1 Sam. 2:1–10) foreshadows many themes in the rest of 1–2 Samuel and how David’s concluding prayer (22:1–51) uses similar language. Note again the similarities, especially in the beginning and the ending of the two bookending prayers.
What differences do you see in the two prayers (see especially 1 Sam. 2:9–10 and 2 Sam. 22:47–51)? In other words, what has changed from the beginning to the end of 1–2 Samuel?
David celebrates God’s many acts of deliverance in his concluding prayer (22:1–51). Recall and write down some of the deliverance stories from earlier in 1–2 Samuel that he likely has in mind.
Consider any one of the deliverance stories you recalled above—how does David’s celebration of deliverance in 2 Samuel 22:1–51 differ from the actual event? What is noteworthy about the language David uses in his praise?
Read through the following three sections on Gospel Glimpses, Whole-Bible Connections, and Theological Soundings. Then take time to consider the Personal Implications these sections may have for you.